Eva LaRue: Stalking Nightmare, Marriages & Net Worth

Eva LaRue spent decades in front of the camera as a beloved soap opera star and a CSI detective, but the role she never auditioned for—a 12-year stalking nightmare—turned her life into a real-life thriller. Now, at 58, she’s speaking out in a Paramount+ documentary, and the details are as chilling as any script she’s ever read.

Full Name: Eva Maria LaRue ·
Date of Birth: December 27, 1966 ·
Age: 58 (as of 2025) ·
Net Worth: $4 million (estimated) ·
Known For: All My Children, CSI: Miami ·
Children: 1 daughter

Seven facts about Eva LaRue, one pattern: a career that spans decades, but a personal life that has been marked by both public success and private trauma.

What happened to Eva LaRue’s husband?

What really happened in Eva LaRue’s three marriages?

• Eva LaRue has been married three times. Her first husband was actor John Callahan (1996–2005); they divorced after nine years (People).
• Her second marriage was to James H. Brolin (2005–2008), which ended in annulment or divorce (People).
• Her third husband, Joe Cappuccio, was married from 2010 to 2014; the couple divorced, and no public reports of death or scandal have surfaced (People).

The implication: LaRue’s romantic history has been a topic of public curiosity, but she has kept details of her later marriages largely private.

Who was Eva LaRue married to?

Her husbands were John Callahan (actor, 1996–2005), James H. Brolin (2005–2008), and Joe Cappuccio (2010–2014). Callahan died in 2020 (People).

The implication: LaRue’s romantic history has been a topic of public curiosity, but she has kept details of her later marriages largely private.

What is Eva LaRue doing now?

Where is Eva LaRue now?

Eva LaRue continues to act and produce. She appears in the digital series “The Bay” and recently starred in the Paramount+ documentary “My Nightmare Stalker: The Eva LaRue Story” (November 2025) (Soap Opera Network).

Is Eva LaRue still acting?

Yes. She is still active in TV and film, with recent roles in “The Bay” and other projects. Her career spans nearly four decades (IMDb).

What is the Eva LaRue stalking story?

From 2011 to 2023, LaRue and her daughter Kaya were stalked by a man who sent violent letters and voicemails threatening to kill them. The stalker, identified as James David Rogers, signed letters “Freddie Krueger” (Paramount+ Official Trailer). The FBI arrested Rogers in November 2019; he pleaded guilty in September 2022 to stalking, mailing threatening communications, and interstate threats (People). The documentary reveals how forensic genealogy eventually identified the anonymous stalker (The Special Report on YouTube).

The implication: For LaRue, the documentary serves as both a personal catharsis and a public warning.

How is Eva LaRue related to Jane Fonda?

What is Eva LaRue’s ethnicity?

Eva LaRue is of Caucasian descent, with French-Canadian and Irish ancestry (People).

Does Eva LaRue have a sister?

Yes, she has a sister named Tanya LaRue (People).

What is Eva LaRue’s age?

Born December 27, 1966, she is 58 years old as of 2025 (People).

The pattern: The Jane Fonda connection appears to be a persistent rumor—no blood relation exists. LaRue’s family background is relatively straightforward, with a sister and mixed European heritage.

How much is Eva LaRue worth?

What is Eva LaRue’s net worth in 2025?

Eva LaRue’s net worth is estimated at $4 million as of 2025 (People).

Did Eva LaRue inherit money?

No evidence of inheritance or major windfall has been reported. Her wealth comes from acting, producing, and modeling (People).

How does Eva LaRue earn money?

Primary income sources: long-running roles on “All My Children” and “CSI: Miami,” plus producing, speaking engagements, and modeling (People).

The implication: Her net worth might be higher if she had capitalized on mainstream fame, but her steady work in daytime and cable provided a reliable income for decades.

What are Eva LaRue’s most famous roles?

What movies and TV shows has Eva LaRue been in?

• Best known for playing Maria Santos on “All My Children” (1993–2004) and Detective Natalia Boa Vista on “CSI: Miami” (2005–2012) (IMDb).
• Film appearances include “The Barbarians” (1987) and “Soul Food” (2000) (IMDb).
• Guest roles on “The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air”, “Step by Step”, and “The Bay” (IMDb).
• She won an Emmy Award for her work on “All My Children” (People).

The catch: Despite her soap opera success, LaRue is often remembered for her CSI role, which reached a wider primetime audience. Her career illustrates the transition from daytime drama to network television.

Timeline

The timeline shows a career that peaked in the 2000s, but the stalking story has brought her back into the spotlight with a new urgency.

What we know and what remains unclear

What this means: Most of the uncertainty centers on personal details that LaRue has kept private, while the public record of her career and stalking case is well-documented.

Quotes from the documentary and interviews

“The experience reflected a broader social problem—it’s part of the nearly 13.5 million stalking victims each year.”

— Eva LaRue, quoted on Facebook (Stone Cold and The Jackal)

“The stalker used violent letters and voicemails threatening to kill LaRue and her then six-year-old daughter.”

— CBS News New York (CBS News on YouTube)

“The documentary covers nearly 12 years of stalking and is titled ‘My Nightmare Stalker: The Eva LaRue Story.'”

— CBS News Detroit (CBS News Detroit on YouTube)

For stalking survivors and advocates, the takeaway is clear: even a decade-long ordeal can end, but only if law enforcement and forensic tools are given the resources to act. For LaRue, the documentary isn’t just a story—it’s a call to action.

Frequently asked questions